Sorry for not posting pictures yet, but my camera isn't compatible with my printer, and I can't seem to figure out how to load pictures on here anyway.
I typically shop at My Safe Bird Store. You'll never regret shopping from here! Everything is packaged up in paper, so it's like opening up a box of gifts! Plus there's usually a few finger trap toys/treats thrown in for the birds and some candy for you!!!! Before I got Jayde, I made a $200 purchase from this store (food and toys) and half the stuff came in "new baby gift bags".
I recently made a purchase from The Birdsafe Store which was alright.
Here's some other stores that I've heard are also great! (need to order from some of them, too!)
California Bird Nerds
Chopper's Toys
Crystal's Bird Toys
I Got A Woody Bird Toys
Mother Pluckin' Bird Toys
Oliver's Garden Bird Toys
Parroteelia Bird Toys
Things for Wings
TNT Bird Toys
Bird on the Rocks
(hope all the links work, not sure that they are all still valid though!)